Is Pizza Cheese Real Cheese?

Click for your Amazon Christmas & New Year shopping
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you

Pizza is one of the most beloved comfort foods worldwide, adored for its crispy crust, savory toppings, and gooey cheese. But have you ever wondered whether the cheese used on your favorite slice is truly "real" cheese? With so many processed and imitation cheese products available in the market, it's understandable to question what exactly goes into that cheesy topping. In this article, we'll explore what constitutes real cheese, how pizza cheese is made, and whether the cheese on your pizza meets the criteria of authentic cheese.

Is Pizza Cheese Real Cheese?

The question of whether pizza cheese is "real" cheese depends on the type of cheese used and the ingredients involved. Many pizzerias and cheese manufacturers use different forms of cheese, ranging from traditional, natural cheeses to processed cheese products. Understanding what makes cheese "real" involves examining its ingredients, production process, and labeling standards.

What Is Real Cheese?

Real cheese is a dairy product made from milk, typically from cows, goats, or sheep, that has undergone fermentation and aging processes. It contains natural ingredients and minimal additives, resulting in a product rich in flavor, texture, and nutritional value.

  • Ingredients: Milk, bacteria (starter cultures), rennet, salt
  • Production process: Coagulation of milk, curd formation, cutting, cooking, pressing, aging
  • Standards: Regulations by food authorities (like FDA in the U.S.) specify that cheese must be made from milk with minimal additives to be labeled as "cheese."

Examples of authentic cheeses include cheddar, mozzarella, gouda, and Swiss. These cheeses are made with natural ingredients and traditional methods, resulting in a product that is genuinely "cheese."

What Is Pizza Cheese Made Of?

Pizza cheese commonly refers to the cheese used as a topping on pizza slices. The most prevalent type globally is mozzarella, but other cheeses like provolone, cheddar, and processed cheese blends are also used. The composition of pizza cheese can vary significantly based on the manufacturer and the desired meltability, flavor, and texture.

Types of Cheese Used on Pizza

  • Fresh Mozzarella: Made from milk, rennet, and cultures, it is minimally processed and retains a high moisture content. It’s considered genuine cheese.
  • Part-Skim Mozzarella: Similar to fresh mozzarella but with reduced fat content, often used in commercial pizzas.
  • Processed Cheese: Includes products like cheese slices or cheese spreads that contain added emulsifiers, stabilizers, and sometimes other non-dairy ingredients.
  • Cheese Blends: Combinations of mozzarella with other cheeses or additives for flavor and meltability.

Ingredients in Processed Pizza Cheese

Many processed pizza cheeses are not just pure cheese but are formulated with various additives to improve shelf life, meltability, and flavor consistency. These ingredients may include:

  • Emulsifiers: To ensure smooth melting and prevent oil separation (e.g., sodium phosphate, sodium citrate)
  • Stabilizers and Thickeners: To improve texture and shelf stability
  • Artificial Colors: To enhance appearance, such as yellow or orange hues
  • Preservatives: To prolong shelf life

Are Processed Cheeses Considered "Real" Cheese?

This is where the debate often arises. According to food labeling standards, for a product to be labeled as "cheese," it must meet specific criteria, including being made from milk and containing certain natural ingredients. However, processed cheese products are often made with a combination of cheese, milk solids, and non-dairy ingredients, which can make them technically different from traditional cheese.

Many industry experts and consumers consider fresh mozzarella and similar naturally made cheeses as "real cheese." In contrast, processed cheese, cheese spreads, and cheese analogs might lack some natural components or contain added non-dairy ingredients, leading some to question their authenticity.

Legal Definitions and Standards

  • United States: The FDA defines cheese as a food product made from milk with specific standards. Processed cheese is classified separately but can still be labeled as "cheese" if it meets certain criteria.
  • European Union: Similar regulations exist, requiring cheese products to be made from milk and traditional processes to be labeled as "cheese."

In essence, if a pizza cheese is made from milk, cultures, rennet, and minimal additives, it qualifies as real cheese. If it contains significant non-dairy ingredients, emulsifiers, or artificial additives, it might be considered processed or imitation cheese.

How to Identify Authentic Pizza Cheese

Knowing whether your pizza cheese is real involves reading labels and understanding the ingredients. Here are some tips:

  • Check the ingredient list: Look for ingredients like milk, rennet, and bacterial cultures. If the list includes emulsifiers, artificial colors, or non-dairy fats, it may be processed cheese.
  • Look for labeling: Terms like "mozzarella," "fresh mozzarella," or "100% cheese" suggest natural cheese. Conversely, labels like "cheese product" or "cheese food" often indicate processed varieties.
  • Ask your pizzeria: Many establishments use fresh, natural cheeses, but some may opt for processed cheese blends for cost and meltability reasons.

Conclusion: Is Pizza Cheese Real Cheese?

In summary, the answer depends on the type of cheese used on your pizza. Traditional, fresh mozzarella made from milk, rennet, and cultures is unquestionably real cheese. It contains natural ingredients and adheres to standard definitions of cheese. However, many commercial pizza cheeses—especially processed cheese slices, cheese blends, and spreads—may contain added emulsifiers, stabilizers, and non-dairy ingredients, making them technically different from traditional cheese products.

Consumers seeking authentic cheese should read labels carefully, ask questions, and opt for pizzas topped with natural, minimally processed cheeses. While processed cheese offers benefits like uniform meltability and longer shelf life, it often lacks the natural complexity and nutritional profile of genuine cheese. Ultimately, understanding what goes into your pizza can help you make informed choices and enjoy your favorite slice with confidence in its ingredients.

Back to blog

Leave a comment